Homemade Vanilla Extract

I remember the first time I heard that you could make your own vanilla extract. It was from my co-worker nearly 15 years ago.  I looked at her like she was crazy; yet I was intrigued at the same time. Follow along as I share my experience with making easy and inexpensive homemade vanilla extract.

That was in a previous life time as a speech language pathologist working full time without babies at home. I was engaged, and the homemaking bug had bitten me. This was a time before you could Google everything for a quick answer. And I hung on every word that my co-worker shared with me.

I was training her as a speech pathologist. And she was training me in homemaking. This was a second career for her, so she had 20 years of life experience on me and graciously shared her knowledge with me as we worked side by side. She had a family goat farm and would make homemade goat milk soap when she got home from a long day at the skilled nursing facility. All these years later, we have long since lost touch, but I remember all of the beautiful things she taught me and I will forever cherish them.

Homemade Vanilla Extract Ingredients:

Making vanilla extract only requires two ingredients.  An organic vodka and organic vanilla beans. I use Madagascar vanilla beans available from Costco.

Materials Recommended:

You’ll also need brown glass bottles to store the finished vanilla extract in and a quart sized mason jar to hold the vodka and vanilla beans while the vanilla beans infuse with the vodka. A small funnel also comes in handy when pouring the extract into the brown bottles.

How to Make Vanilla Extract:

Start by slicing the vanilla beans lengthwise down own side. Keeping the other side of the vanilla bean intact. 

Place 3 to 5 beans in the quart size mason jar. Then, fill the jar with a good quality vodka. Be sure to cover the vanilla beans fully with vodka. Beans left uncovered by vodka can get moldy.

Put the lid on the mason jar and give it a good shake to start infusing the vodka and vanilla beans together. 

Store the jar in the pantry, cupboard, or dark corner of the countertop. I keep mine in the corner of the countertop so that I remember to give it a shake once and a while.

Let your vanilla infuse for 6 to 12 months depending on the preferred strength of the desired vanilla flavor.

When you’re done making vanilla extract,  don’t throw away your vanilla beans. Just refill with fresh vodka. I like to add a few new vanilla beans to my vodka mason jar every year or two. I think I currently have ten to twelve vanilla beans in my jar.

Now that the vanilla extract is ready, store it in brown glass bottles with a lid. One quart of vanilla extract should fill four, 8-ounce bottles. I also keep a little brown vanilla bottle next to my salt and pepper and olive oil near the stove for easy access near the stove.

Save money by making your own vanilla extract

Vanilla extract from the grocery store is outrageously priced. If you have a little patience, you can make 32 ounces of vanilla extract for about $1.25 an ounce vs. $3.50 an ounce for store bought organic vanilla extract.

I use vanilla in so many recipes.  But the one where the vanilla is really the star of the dish is my raw milk vanilla ice cream recipe.

Thanks for stopping by and following along. For more homemade family inspiration and recipes, visit @homesteadonlakeside

This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no cost to you. Thanks for your support!

24 responses to “Homemade Vanilla Extract”

  1. Mid-Life Mama Avatar

    This is very timely as I stood in awe at the cost of vanilla in Wegmans recently. The bottle I previously paid $9 for (and cringed paying it) is up to $22. Seriously? I took a pic and sent it to others who wouldn’t have believed it without visual proof!

    What a special time in your life when that woman invested in you! Those types of homemaking skills are a rare find.

    1. Rachel Avatar

      Good morning ☀️ Isn’t it crazy how expensive groceries have become?! I’m glad this post was timely. $22 is just too much!
      Yes, such a special time in my life. I don’t think she realizes how much she taught me. 💕

  2. Looking for the Light Avatar

    Love it! I didn’t know it was made with vodka. I love fresh goat milk as long as it has eaten good grass vs. weeds. I’ve only had 4-5 times and the few times I’ve tried fresh organic Goat Milk it’s not the same. What a great friendship. the blessing in life.

    1. Rachel Avatar

      Such a blessing 💕 I feel like it’s hard to find mentors like that nowadays.

      1. Looking for the Light Avatar

        Yes, indeed probably harder than ever. that’s why the are so special when do find them.

  3. Victoria Avatar

    Who knew?! Not me! Thanks, Rachel. And I’ve gotta say…I love the photo of your supplies next to the stove. Something about the wooden spoons, a few ingredients, seasonings in pretty containers lit by a lovely lamp. Super inviting. You do that so well. xo! 🥰

    1. Rachel Avatar

      Aw, thanks Victoria! I love that little corner of my kitchen too. 🥰

      1. Victoria Avatar

        🥰

  4. Mary K. Doyle Avatar

    How does the flavor of homemade vanilla compare to store-bought, Rachel?

    1. Rachel Avatar

      Hi Mary, I think it’s even more delicious and flavorful. Thanks for stopping by. Have a great evening!

  5. Spark of Inspiration Avatar
    Spark of Inspiration

    Vodka, interesting. You’ve taught us something new. That was fun.

    1. Rachel Avatar

      I know, I was surprised as well when I learned how it was traditionally made. Thanks for stopping by 💕

  6. 100 Country Trek Avatar

    Yes I saw this homemade vanilla. Rachel this amazing vanilla. Anita

    1. Rachel Avatar

      Thank you Anita!

  7. Mama Avatar

    I learn something new from you every time I read your posts, it’s incredible! I always wanted to make homemade Vanilla extract and now I can. Saved under my favourites and will have to look for the vanilla at Costco next time I go….hopefully we have it at the Canadian Costco. Thanks for sharing Rachel!

    1. Rachel Avatar

      Aw, you’re so kind. Thanks for all of the compliments! I hope your costco has it too!! 🥰

  8. Keto Queen Recipes Avatar

    great post – thanks !!

    Download 50 Amazing Keto Recipes –> https://ketodietrecipes.co.uk/

  9. K.L. Hale Avatar

    Rachel, how did I miss this? I’m going to make my vanilla! What a wonderful mentor and friend you had; now, YOU are that to US! Thank you for your years of serving–and now, as a Momma giving back, too! You’re a blessing to all of us! Love and hugs, sweet lady!

    1. Rachel Avatar

      You always know just the right thing to say to fill my cup. I’m so thankful for your friendship. Sending big hugs!! 🥰

      1. K.L. Hale Avatar

        Aww, I’m so glad, my friend. I feel that way about you, too! I feel the hugs! Yay! 💕🤗❣️

  10. Garance Avatar

    I loved the short tribute to your co-worker. It’s funny how meaningful relationships can bring us inspiration, support, and even amazing recipes…

    1. Rachel Avatar

      Thank you! I wish I was still in touch with her. I’m thankful that I have the memory of our time together. I hope you had a great weekend!

  11. […] tsp of vanilla extract (see my post here on how to make your own homemade vanilla […]

  12. […] 2 tsp of vanilla (Check out how to make your own homemade vanilla extract here.) […]

Leave a Reply

I’m Rachel

Welcome to Homestead on Lakeside! I love sharing how our family lives a homemade and budget friendly lifestyle through recipes from scratchsourdough, and homeschool ideas.

Let’s connect

Discover more from Homestead on Lakeside

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading